Epic | E-learning Debate, 27th January

The E-learning Debate at Learning Technologies 2010

This house believes that learning on smart phones is less about new technology than it is about a new approach to pedagogy

Click below to cast your vote

Vote for

Vote against

Arguing for the motion

Professor John Traxler: Professor of Mobile Learning at the University of Wolverhampton. Also, Director of Learning Lab, Director of the International Association for Mobile Learning and Associate Editor of the International Journal of Mobile and Blended Learning. Author of numerous books and papers.
Mr Kim Whittlestone: Senior Lecturer in Independent Learning at Royal Veterinary College with an interest in mobile learning. Kim played a major role in the establishment and development of e-learning centres at the Universities of Bristol and Cambridge.

The Argument for

Introduction
This motion is about 'mobile learning'. Mobile learning used to be defined in terms of learning with mobile devices, any mobile devices, not just smart phones. It is now defined in terms of learning: learning and mobility, learning across contexts, learning adapted and aligned to societies increasingly characterised by mobility and connectedness. Mobile learning is transforming what we know and how we know it, what we learn and how we learn it.

Arguing against the motion

Professor Mike Sharples: Professor of Learning Sciences and Director of the Learning Sciences Research Institute at the University of Nottingham. Inaugurator of the mLearn international conference series, President of the International Association for Mobile Learning, and key member of the STELLAR European Network of Excellence in Technology-Enhanced Learning.
Dr Mike Short: Vice President of Research and Development for O2, and Chair of the UK Mobile Data Association. Visiting professor at Surrey University and member of the board of Coventry University. Previously, part of the UK Home Office Internet Task Force.

The Argument against

Introduction
The pedagogy of mobile learning isn't new. Nearly 100 years ago, the educational reformer John Dewey advocated inquiry-based learning. In the mid 20th century Paolo Friere proposed learning through conversation and dialogue. And more recently Clark Abt introduced the notion of 'serious games' as a way to learn. All these liberating theories of pedagogy benefit from modern technology, such as smart phones, to turn them into successful practices.

Previous Debates

The E-learning Debate at the Oxford Union 2010

Click here to register your interest.

Paste this content into your blog profile or web page:

Click here to find out more about smartphone learning.

Use this QR (bar) code to access learning on your mobile.

Click here to follow the
e-learning debate

8 February 2010 Kim Whittlestone asks when on your phone, are you texting, emailing, note-taking... learning? See video highlights at elearningdebate.com
8 February 2010 elearningdebate.com - 144 votes so far. Have you read the arguements, viewed the highlights and voted? Discuss, debate, don't miss out!

View images from the
e-learning debate at Learning Technologies

View more photos

Watch extracts from the
e-learning debate at Learning Technologies

The E-learning Debate 2010 - Highlights

Epic Performance Improvement Limited